Dependency Hell

image source: https://assets.browserlondon.com/

Have you ever come across a situation where the application you have been working on, it just starts behaving abruptly in some environments while it works fine in the other ones or maybe something like a Class Not Found error or worst of all the build itself doesn’t go through without giving a proper error. You just entered the Dependency Hell my friend — where your sanity goes to die, and your project decides to take a spontaneous vacation to Dysfunction Junction. If you’ve ever found yourself wondering why your seemingly innocent codebase has turned into a volatile powder keg, congratulations! You might just be a lucky victim of the dreaded dependency hell.

image source: https://sourcegraphstatic.com/

Dependency hell is a situation that occurs when a software application is unable to access the additional programs it requires to function properly. These additional programs, known as dependencies, are necessary for the software to run, but they can sometimes cause conflicts and issues. It can also be referred as Jar hell (in case of jar dependencies), Class Conflict and Version Skew.

Imagine there are three modules: A, B, and C. A requires B at v1.0, and C also requires B, but at v2.0. We can visualize this like so:

image source: https://npm.github.io/

Now, let’s create an application that requires both module A and module C.

image source: https://npm.github.io/

A package manager would need to provide a version of module B. In all other runtimes, this is what a package manager would try to do. This is dependency hell:

image source: https://npm.github.io/

Now what do you think can happen here? Your App just got confused my dear developer. Now either it will result in build failure (if it is a compile time dependency) or something like class not found error or even it might run but the behaviour will be unexpected, some functions might just not run (if it is a runtime dependency).

Let’s dive into the signs that your project is in this delightful state and how you can confirm your misfortune.

Signs You’ve Entered Dependency Hell

1. Runtime Exceptions:
   Ah yes, the comforting sight of errors like NoClassDefFoundError, NoSuchMethodError, and ClassCastException. Nothing says “fun” like tracking down why your perfectly fine code just imploded because two libraries can’t agree on which version of a class to use.
2. Build Failures:
   Ever tried to build your project and got greeted with messages about version conflicts or missing dependencies? It’s like your build tool is laughing at you, saying, “Nice try, but no.”
3. Inconsistent Behavior:
   Does your code work in development but break in production? Perfect! You’ve achieved the ultimate developer paradox, thanks to different environments resolving dependencies in their unique, chaotic ways.
4. Dependency Resolution Errors:
   Tools like Maven, Gradle, npm, or pip love to throw cryptic dependency resolution errors. These little gems tell you that your dependencies are at war, and you’re the unfortunate peacemaker.
5. Excessive or Redundant Dependencies:
   When your project’s dependency list starts looking like a hoarder’s garage, with multiple versions of the same library cluttering up your classpath or module path, you know you’ve hit the jackpot.

For your information Dependency hell is a common issue not just in Java or JavaScript, but in many other programming languages and ecosystems. Here are examples from several other languages where developers can encounter similar issues:

JavaScript / Node.js

• npm / yarn:
  Dependency hell can occur due to the nested nature of dependencies. Different packages might depend on different versions of the same library, leading to issues with modules not being compatible.
• Tools like npm dedupe and yarn resolutions can help mitigate these issues.

Python

• pip / conda:
  Python’s dependency issues often arise from conflicting versions of packages. This can lead to errors if different parts of a project require different versions of a package.
• Virtual environments (venv, virtualenv) and tools like pipenv or poetry help manage dependencies and isolate them to avoid conflicts.

Ruby

• RubyGems / Bundler:
  Ruby projects can face dependency hell when gems (Ruby packages) have conflicting dependencies or when gem versions are incompatible.
• Bundler manages gem dependencies and versions, helping to mitigate these issues by ensuring that all dependencies are compatible with each other.

PHP

• Composer:
  In PHP, dependency hell can occur with Composer when different packages require different versions of the same dependency.
• Composer uses a dependency resolution algorithm to try to find a set of versions that satisfy all constraints, but manual intervention is sometimes required to resolve conflicts.

.NET

• NuGet:
  .NET projects using NuGet can encounter issues with package versions, especially when multiple libraries depend on different versions of the same package.
• Tools and features within NuGet, such as dependency version conflict resolution and assembly binding redirects, help manage these issues.

C / C++

• Package Managers (e.g., vcpkg, Conan):
  Dependency management in C/C++ can be complex due to binary compatibility issues and different versions of libraries.
• These package managers help manage dependencies, but conflicts can still arise when different libraries require different versions of a common dependency.

Rust

• Cargo:
  Rust’s package manager, Cargo, can also encounter dependency conflicts, known as “dependency hell,” when different crates (Rust packages) require incompatible versions of the same dependency.
• Cargo uses a resolver to find a compatible set of dependencies, but sometimes developers need to manually intervene to resolve conflicts.

Haskell

• Cabal / Stack:
  Haskell projects using Cabal or Stack can face dependency hell due to conflicting versions of packages (Hackage packages).
• Stack’s curated snapshots help mitigate this issue by ensuring that a set of package versions are tested to work together.

Elixir

• Mix:
  Elixir projects using Mix can also face dependency hell when dependencies have conflicting requirements.
• Mix provides tools to specify and resolve dependencies, but manual resolution might be necessary when conflicts arise.

In all these languages and ecosystems, dependency hell generally stems from the same root cause: different parts of a project (or different projects) requiring incompatible versions of the same dependencies. Effective dependency management tools and practices are crucial in mitigating these issues, but understanding the specific tools and techniques for each ecosystem is essential for developers.

Now the question arises, how to get out of this stupid and really confusion place.

image source: https://cdn.activestate.com/

1. Inspect Dependency Tree
   Why not start by peering into the abyss? Use your build tool to vomit out the full dependency tree and see the carnage for yourself:
   Maven: mvn dependency:treeGradle: ./gradlew dependenciesnpm: npm lspip: pip list or pipdeptree Composer: composer show -t
2. Analyze Classpath or Module Path
   Just to add to your misery, check the classpath or module path. Ensure there are no duplicate or conflicting JARs or modules. It’s like searching for a needle in a needlestack.
3. Review Error Messages
   Those error messages and stack traces? They’re your new bedtime reading. They often drop hints about which classes or modules are causing the drama and the versions involved.
4. Check for Duplicate Libraries
   Wander through your project’s dependencies folder and revel in the sight of multiple versions of the same library. Nothing like redundancy to make your day!
5. Use Dependency Management Tools
   Because who doesn’t love more tools to learn? Employ plugins and commands to wrangle your dependencies:
   Maven Enforcer Plugin:

<plugin>
    <groupId>org.apache.maven.plugins</groupId>
    <artifactId>maven-enforcer-plugin</artifactId>
    <version>3.0.0-M3</version>
    <executions>
        <execution>
            <id>enforce</id>
            <goals>
                <goal>enforce</goal>
            </goals>
            <configuration>
                <rules>
                    <DependencyConvergence/>
                </rules>
            </configuration>
        </execution>
    </executions>
</plugin>

Gradle Resolution Strategy:

configurations.all {
    resolutionStrategy {
        force 'com.fasterxml.jackson.core:jackson-databind:2.12.3'
    }
}

6. Manual Inspection
When all else fails, roll up your sleeves and manually inspect your dependency declarations (pom.xml, build.gradle, package.json, requirements.txt). Because why automate when you can suffer?

Conclusion

In the end, recognizing and escaping from dependency hell is just another rite of passage in the developer’s journey. With enough patience and a pinch of masochism, you too can navigate through this labyrinth of conflicts. Or, you know, consider a career change.